Being 17 - The Colorless Colored Boy

Being 17, the latest offering of the acclaimed French auteur, André Téchiné, at 73 is a visually gorgeous film. It tells of a lust/hate relationship that develops between two adolescent boys (no prize for guessing their age) in the rural French high school they go to. Smart and sensitive queer-in-incubation Damien (Kacey Mottet Klein) stares longingly at his beautiful bi-racial classmate, Thomas (Corentin Fila), igniting the latter’s antagonism and initiating a protracted series of physical fights.


Through a series of convenient plot twists, Thomas comes to live with Damien and his physician mother for a time, which does nothing to dampen the sexual tension between them but does finally prod Damien into coming out both to his understanding mother and to Thomas himself. “I don’t know if I’m into guys,” he tells Thomas, “or just you.” Thomas’ initial reaction reveals his deep ambivalence but he eventually gives into the lust on his own side.


The plot itself brings nothing knew to the well-worn tropes of gay adolescent coming-of-age, coming out stories. There is always the lover and the beloved. And there are only two outcomes. Either the beloved returns the lover’s affection or he doesn’t. In Being 17, Thomas does return the love, and there are two tasteful-but-stimulating sex scenes between the boys to prove it. And just for that dash of political correctness, they both top one another.


The film is beautiful, as I noted before, and the whiteness of the mountainous winter scenery makes Thomas’ darker beauty stand out all the more. With no backstory presented as to his biological origins, Thomas drops into this literally white world as the adopted son of a cattle farming couple, both of whom are grounded, loving parents. (Everybody in this film is, as the French would say, “hyper-kool.”) What’s notable, when you look at Being 17 through a racial lens is how invisible race is. Thomas loves his mountains, his cattle, his white parents. There is no trace of Black identity in his persona. At one point when the constant fighting between Thomas and Damien comes to the attention of the school principal, he says that Thomas fits the profile of a bully. That’s as close to a racial stereotype as the movie gets. (‘Cause, you know, black men are given to violence.) The movie takes a voyeuristic pleasure (as does Damien) in Thomas’ well-built naked body. That’s par for the course and aesthetically done.


Thomas’ blackness, a blackness of appearance only, is entirely beside the point. His role could have been given to a white actor, and nothing would have to have changed. This isn’t exactly color-blind casting, as the musical Hamilton has so famously done with the Founding Fathers. It’s more like colorless casting. (I wanted to write a review of Patrick Ian Polk’s 2012 narrative, The Skinny, an ensemble romantic comedy about Black gays and lesbians, but that too featured a colorless script – no racial issues come up for any of the characters.)


This isn’t necessarily a bad thing. In a famous essay, “Everybody’s Protest Novel,” James Baldwin complained that when “the negro” was introduced to the pages of American literature, it was always as a problem or in reaction to white society’s prevailing racism. In that regard, colorless casting—while perhaps conjuring a post-racial utopia that can never come to pass (pace the Obama presidency)—represents an advance in consciousness. Then again, perhaps not.

Recent Posts

richard barthe is standing next to a statue of a man
By Dr. Robert Philipson 01 May, 2024
Of the many visual artists born at the turn of the last century who came of age during the Harlem Renaissance, only one has been pegged (no pun intended!) as unambiguously gay -- Richmond Barthé. Perhaps because of this odd underrepresentation (I mean, isn't any boy who dabbles in the arts under suspicion?), the visual arts haven't figured much, or at all, in any inventory of the Queer Harlem Renaissance. (Not that there's been such an inventory, but rest assured, it's coming!)
A black and white photo of a man speaking into a microphone
By Dr. Robert Philipson 03 Apr, 2024
We want poems like fists beating niggers out of Jocks or dagger poems in the slimy bellies of the owner-jews. These lines, published in a much-anthologized poem written in 1966, spurted from the pen of the most influential and widely known Black writer/poet in America, Amiri Baraka. The poem, “Black Art,” advocated a poetry of violence and revenge: “Poems that wrestle cops into alleys/and take their weapons/ leaving them dead/with tongues pulled out and sent to Ireland.” Other enemies of Black liberation get their meed of bile, but Jews are called out three times, including the invocation of “Another bad poem cracking/steel knuckles in a jewlady's mouth.”
two women are hugging each other in a black and white photo .
By Dr. Robert Philipson 06 Mar, 2024
In 1950, the superstar singer and actor Ethel Waters checked off another box in her list of African American firsts when she starred in a weekly television series, Beulah. As the name indicates, Beulah was a maid whose raison d'être was to serve her white employers, "Mr. and Mrs. Henderson," and act as a nanny to their son, "Donnie." Although Waters brought as much warmth and humor as she could to the stereotype, the other Black characters portrayed were even flatter and more offensive: "Bill," the unemployed beau who is a braggart and a screw-up; and "Oriole," a ditzy maid (played by Butterfly McQueen, no less!) who works for the family next door.
a man and a woman are sitting next to each other in a black and white photo .
By Dr. Robert Philipson 13 Feb, 2024
In 1931, James P. Johnson wrote and recorded a song, "Go Harlem," extolling the extraordinary life of New York's Black Mecca. Among the lyrics: "Like Van Vechten/Start inspection'./Go Harlem!/Go Harlem!/Go Harlem/ Startin' right now." Carl Van Vechten, a white writer, music critic, journalist, photographer, and tastemaker, was such an integral part of the Harlem Renaissance that within the artistic and intellectual circles of the movement he needed no introduction. Hence, the lyric penned by the incomparable Andy Razaf.
Share by: